Current Postings

July 22, 2014: A Proud and Anguished Heart

Before I share news, I want to take the liberty of talking, first, about the anguish in my heart – the tears that I carry inside of me - because of this war we are fighting.

There is, above all, the sense of loss that fine young Israeli men in the prime of their lives are being taken down by the enemy.  I mourn them, and the circumstances that have brought them to their deaths. (see below)

But there is more: There is the sense of inherent and breathtaking injustice that is at the core of what is going on. 

I’ve seen it expressed in several different contexts over the years: Muslim Arabs, who face us as enemies, crow that they have a tactical advantage because “Just as they [the Jews] love life, so do we love death.”  While we seek to protect our people, they find theirs dispensable. And oh, what a diabolical imbalance that generates.

~~~~~~~~~~

“Might-have-been-horrors” don’t count for the world. 

It’s true with regard to the rocket attacks from Hamas. They have launched way over 1,000 rockets since the beginning of the war.  If they had been successful, many many Israeli civilians would have been killed and enormous damage would have been done.  But we have the Iron Shield anti-missile defense and a homefront defense that seeks to protect civilians. So the world pays no attention to the maliced intent of Hamas or to the fact that they are committing war crimes.

In recent days, as well, we’ve caught several Hamas terrorists coming through tunnels on their way to generating massacre and mayhem in Israel.  But that’s the point. We were on the lookout and we caught them. 

The world clearly has no imagination about what would have happened, had the Shin Bet and the IDF not been diligent. 

So let me provide a reminder.  Three years ago, terrorists made their way into the community of Itamar and slaughtered the Fogel family.  Among those killed was a three month old baby.  Her throat was slit. 

Credit: Hezbos

When the terrorists were caught, they expressed pride in what they had done.  Bodily mutilation is the norm, you see, when they murder Jews.

So the world may not care, or may choose to look away. But we here in Israel know.  The possibilities have been seared into our national consciousness.  We know what would happen – Heaven forbid! – if terrorists utilizing tunnels made their way into our communities. 

We know that we must do all that we can to assure that this does not happen.  This means taking out those tunnels.  It’s the obligation of the government and the IDF to see it done, to protect the people of Israel.

~~~~~~~~~~

But we are dealing with a diabolical enemy that is pleased to sacrifice its own people in order to make matters difficult for us.  Just as their rockets are stored in and launched from civilian places such as mosques and schools, so are the entrances to the tunnels located in civilian areas. Some tunnels open up inside of houses.  Maybe underneath someone’s bed.  Or under mosques.

We warn the civilians that they should leave before we launch an attack – an attack that is essential for the safety of Israeli civilians.  What other nation in the world does this??  I do not believe there has ever been another.  I don’t believe there ever will be another.  It actually puts us at a tactical disadvantage because Hamas knows where we are about to attack.  But does the world notice? Are we praised?  Of course not.

For the local civilians are told by Hamas not to leave when Israel advises them to do so.  They are encouraged to be “martyrs” for their great cause.  Being a martyr means dying in an Israeli attack so that Hamas can leverage the death against us in a PR blitz.  Dead Arab women and children are Hamas’s weapon.  It’s made to look as if Israel uncaringly or deliberately launches attacks on innocents.

More anguish.  There is no joy for us in killing children. 

~~~~~~~~~~

In various places in the world from Paris to Boston  (pictured), there are orgiastic demonstrations of hatred towards Israel going on.  Because we are “child killers.” 


Credit: Israelagainstterror

The venom of anti-Semitism flows in the veins of these demonstrators. But their maliced views of Israel are stoked by left leaning media that can only be described as anti-Semitic as well. (There is no difference between irrational anti-Israel attitudes – imbalanced reportage - and anti-Semitism.)

With it all, they’ve had help from the American secretary of state.  John Kerry had been advised by Israeli officials that we were attempting to do pinpoint operations that would minimize collateral damage.  After having done an interview, and when he mistakenly thought the mike was off, he said, “It’s a hell of a pinpoint operation.  A hell of a pinpoint operation. We’ve got to get over there [to push a ceasefire].”  See it here:

 http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/hot-mic-kerry-mocks-israel-hell-pinpoint-operation_796808.html

And so a pox on the houses of all those who judge us wrongly and all those who wish us ill.

In the end, we know who we are, and we must account only to Heaven.

~~~~~~~~~~

Because of who we are, my heart is also filled with pride. And when the anguish has dissolved, the pride will remain.  I could not be more proud to be an Israeli.  I could not be more proud of who the Israeli people are.  Very, very far from perfect, we are heads and shoulders above the rest of the world.

Israeli Ambassador to the US Ron Dermer, bless him, says that: “...the Israeli Defense Forces should be given the Nobel Peace Prize… a Nobel Peace Prize for fighting with unimaginable restraint.”
 
Reminding his audience that the British had carpet bombed Germany after being attacked, he said, “I will not accept, and no one should accept, criticism of Israel for acting with restraint that has not been shown and would not be shown by any nation on earth. I especially will not tolerate criticism of my country at a time when Israeli soldiers are dying so that innocent Palestinians can live.” (All emphasis added)

“Israel did not have to send its soldiers into many of the places they are fighting today. We could have...bombed from the air all the buildings that were being used by fighters to store and fire weapons. But we didn’t. As we have done time after time, we are sending our soldiers into this hornet’s nest of Palestinian terror that is booby-trapped with mines and riddled with subterranean tunnels.”

 http://www.timesofisrael.com/dermer-idf-deserves-nobel-peace-prize-for-unimaginable-restraint/
 

~~~~~~~~~~

See some of the beautiful soldiers of the IDF (with thanks to Chana G):

http://youtu.be/4IkwXf18FcQ 

They sing of not being afraid, and of putting trust in Heaven. This video made me weep.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Here in Israel we have “lone soldiers.”  Young men who have come to Israel and joined the IDF, while their families are still abroad.  One such lone soldier died in battle the other day: Nissim Sean Carmeli, originally of South Padre Island, Texas. and more recently of Haifa.  The Maccabi soccer team of Haifa put out a call to its fans to attend his funeral “so that his funeral will not be empty.”  More than 12,000 people came.
 
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/183181#.U86mgpvlrIV
 
This, my friends, is Israel with its largeness of heart.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
We have lost 27 soldiers to date in Gaza.
 
A couple of days ago, Hamas announced it had kidnapped a soldier in Gaza, but Israel denied this was the case. 
 
Also two days ago a Personnel Carrier in Gaza that was carrying seven soldiers ran over a device that exploded, causing a fire in the carrier.  The original announcement was that the seven had died.  Now we are being told that only six soldiers’ bodies have been positively identified.  I need not spell out the ugly and painful circumstances that have caused a delay in doing this identification. 
 
The one soldier whose remains have not been identified has now been identified as Oren Shaul, which is the person Hamas said it had kidnapped. 
 

Credit:IsraelMatzav

The very best information I have at this point is that while he must be listed MIA until his body is located and identified, the working assumption is that he is, indeed, dead. Hamas may have grabbed his body – although I have heard that the site was under surveillance after the grisly event.  Or, his dogtag may have been thrown a distance away in the explosion, and grabbed by Hamas.  It has been noted that Hamas, after the initial jubilant announcement, has not put up any video of him – which would have been expected for them to make their case.
 
~~~~~~~~~~

Now as to that “ceasefire” that various international agents are pushing.  Eventually, certainly. But it is not going to happen so fast, I’m pleased to report.  Consider some of the elements in play:

[]  Abbas went to Doha, Qatar to meet with head of the Hamas politburo Khaled Mashaal regarding a ceasefire.  Word was that Mashaal was agreeable and was going to come to Cairo to pursue matters further.  However, Ismail Haniyeh, Hamas leader sitting directly in Gaza (and identified for some time now as more militant than Mashaal), says that his movement has decided to “end the blockade with its blood and weapons and there would be no return back.” 
 
In other words, he is holding out for a lifting of the naval blockade of Gaza, which is not going to happen.  He is also still demanding the release of the prisoners originally traded for Shalit who had been rearrested recently, something Israel is opposed to as well.

Commented Netanyahu to Sky News Arabic, “If Hamas really wants a cease-fire, I am sure that we can get to that, but they don’t want one.”

http://www.jpost.com/Operation-Protective-Edge/US-UN-pushing-hard-for-immediate-cease-fire-368386
 
As long as Hamas is holding out, we keep fighting.  Terms that are mutually acceptable are going to be hard to come by.  Hamas wants a victory and Israel will not give it one.
 
~~~~~~~~~~

At the same time, Israel, having not yet done all that must be done, at a bare minimum, is not looking for a ceasefire anyway.
 
UN Secretary General Ban Ki Moon came calling in Jerusalem today. Israel, Netanyahu told him, will “act decisively to end the threat to its citizens.”  It’s time for the international community to hold Hamas responsible for its behavior:  “The international community must take a clear stance...
 
”I believe that you understand this, it is the right of every state to defend itself, and Israel will do what it needs to do to defend ourselves.

This is not only our right, this is our duty.”  (all emphasis added)

https://warsclerotic.wordpress.com/2014/07/22/netanyahu-rejects-cease-fire-ban-ki-moon-suports-israel/

The prime minister knows that the nation is solidly behind him if he stands strong in continuing to fight. This is a long post, and it’s impossible here for me to fully convey the sense of the Israeli public with regard to wanting the IDF to keep going.

~~~~~~~~~~

Lastly, we have this:
 
Kerry, who had declared, “we must get over there,” arrived in Cairo today.  Master diplomat that this deluded man perceives himself to be, he was coming to make sure that a ceasefire was put in place without delay.
 
But when Kerry and his top aides showed up for a meeting with Egyptian President Sisi – oops! - Egyptian security checked them with metal detectors. This is absolutely unheard of, as top American diplomats are routinely offered every courtesy.  Sisi has “dissed” the secretary of state. 
 
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/07/22/kerry-security-check-egypt_n_5608923.html
 
This contempt from Sisi has been well earned by Kerry.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
© Arlene Kushner. This material is produced by Arlene Kushner, functioning as an independent journalist. Permission is granted for it to be reproduced only with proper attribution. 
 
If it is reproduced and emphasis is added, the fact that it has been added must be noted.

 http://arlenefromisrael.squarespace.com/current-postings/2014/7/22/july-22-2014-a-proud-and-anguished-heart.html

 

Posted on Tuesday, July 22, 2014 at 03:56PM by Registered CommenterArlene in , , , , , , , | CommentsPost a Comment | EmailEmail | PrintPrint

July 21, 2014: War Update

Today was a day on which I had planned to skip posting.  A busy day, starting with an event in the Knesset this morning (about which more in time). But I know I must write to update my readers, even if very briefly.
 
After I had written yesterday, news was released of 13 soldiers who died late Saturday night during the operation in Shejaia, near Gaza City.  They were all from the Golani Brigade.  Terribly painful news. Sad news, pulling at our entire nation.
 
http://www.jpost.com/Operation-Protective-Edge/Seven-Golani-soldiers-killed-in-Gaza-363528
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
The battle in which they died was the biggest of this war, and one in which the IDF accomplished a great deal with regard to identifying and destroying tunnels, locating rockets, etc.
 
Later in the day yesterday, Prime Minister Netanyahu addressed the nation, in order to offer comfort and strength (emphasis added):
 
The heart of the entire nation is with the families of the fallen. We feel your pain. We bow our head to your sons who fell so that we can continue living here. On behalf of the Government and the entire People of Israel, I would like to express the deep pain that we feel. We send our condolences to the parents, children, spouses and families of the IDF soldiers who have fallen in defense of the State of Israel.

“I would like to say to you that there is no war more just than that in which your sons and ours heroically fell. We will complete the mission that we have begun. We will restore quiet and security to the south, the center and the entire country.

“On behalf of all of you, citizens of Israel, I would like to send best wishes for a quick recovery to all the wounded soldiers. I believe that each one of us knows someone who is participating in the campaign, and mutual guarantee is also the secret of our strength. We must be strong in difficult days such as today as well as those that are likely to come. We are in a war for our home. Our forces are currently active in the field; they are operating professionally, with determination, great strength, great firepower and great strength of spirit.

“Soldiers of the IDF, I would like to tell you that the citizens of Israel are behind you and are praying for your welfare.

“To the dear families, I would like to say that I am aware of your concern, we all share it. We are doing our utmost to secure the lives of our citizens and of our soldiers.

“Israel did not choose to enter this campaign but from the moment it was forced on us, we will carry it out to achieve the goal of restoring quiet to Israel's citizens for a prolonged period while inflicting a significant blow on the infrastructures of Hamas and the other terrorist organizations in Gaza. We are not deterred and we will continue to act as necessary. The current operation is necessary to for the security of Israel's citizens...”
 
http://imra.org.il/story.php3?id=64399
 
~~~~~~~~~~

The words of comfort are on the mark, appropriate and gracious.  His statement about the necessity of fighting this war is absolutely true.  Those who died, gave their lives with purpose.
 
And he speaks with strong determination.
 
It is difficult, however, to get a clear sense of the goals for this war from the words of the prime minister, or the minister of defense.  Not clear when the end of the ground operation will be declared or when the shelling by air and sea will stop. I would say this is how it should be, to keep the enemy off balance. There is talk about seeing through the operation to its end (whatever “end” means).  But Defense Minister also speaks about the days (two or three) necessary to eliminate the tunnels.
 
This is what I see now:
 
The wagons of “ceasefire” are circling and it will become more and more difficult to continue in the face of international pressure.  Kerry is due in Cairo tomorrow to work on a ceasefire plan.  (Not that Kerry matters.)  Ban Ki Moon is making noises about how excessive our operation is.  (Not that Ban Ki Moon matters).  But more difficult.
 
Under no circumstances do I see us withdrawing from the ground in Gaza until we are satisfied we have done what we need to do with the tunnels.  That job is not done yet.  Just this morning 10 terrorists attempted again to infiltrate inside Israel, using two different tunnels. They were taken out because of a Shin Bet warning.
 
This risk has to be eliminated or Israelis will live forever on the edge, with terrorist murders and kidnappings not uncommon.
 
Will every single tunnel be identified and eliminated? There is such a network of those tunnels, that this is difficult to say. But every attempt is being made, and in particular with regard to the tunnels that go into Israel or head in that direction.  They really need to be eliminated.
 
It is this that is estimated to require another two or three days of intensive effort by our troops.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Will we continue beyond that time that is essential regarding the tunnels?  I would guess that it depends on the military and diplomatic situation. 
 
We have at this point eliminated at least 50% if not more of Hamas’s rocket supply – and will, of course, continue to take out more in the days ahead (remember, there are rockets stored in the tunnels, as well as elsewhere).  But there is no way that it will be possible to have eliminated every rocket.  This is especially so as rockets are hidden in civilian areas – in schools and mosques. What we will have done, at a minimum, is strike a blow that will serve as a long time deterrent to this terrorist group, which have been seriously depleted and demoralized.  Then it remains to be seen what sort of ceasefire is negotiated.  Netanyahu has in mind some sort of confiscation of the rockets by the international community.  I am not going to discuss that here.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
I know there are those (and some of my readers among them) who think we should “go all the way”: taking down Hamas and taking over Gaza.  Maybe it will happen – and from a purely emotional perspective it seems great - but I tend to doubt it. What is more, I am not sure it would be a good thing.  A seriously weakened Hamas might be the better option right now.
 
There are several factors to remember:
 
[] There are jihadists even more radical and vicious than Hamas, such as al-Qaeda, in Gaza.  To eliminate Hamas would be to make room for them.  This is a critical factor that must not be discounted.
 
[] To literally take over Gaza lock, stock and barrel is to assume an incredible burden, and at a great cost.  It talks easy from an arm chair.  It would not be easy.
 
[] To become enmeshed in handling a long term operation and then management of Gaza might be unwise considering that our military must focus on multiple fronts. Remember that Hezbollah is at our north, as are jihadists in Syria at the border of the Golan.  We will undoubtedly have other battles to fight.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
One last matter: As I have mentioned before, Hamas is trying desperately, in its last gasp, to score a “victory.” This is why we are seeing all of those incursions into Israel now.
 
Last night they tried something else as well: They put out a story that they had kidnapped an Israeli soldier in Gaza – a horrible prospect. Turns out that this is not true.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Please, share this video that shows how the Israeli military operates:
 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j16xIxZdqgg&list=UUawNWlihdgaycQpO3zi-jYg&index=10
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
© Arlene Kushner. This material is produced by Arlene Kushner, functioning as an independent journalist. Permission is granted for it to be reproduced only with proper attribution. 
 
If it is reproduced and emphasis is added, the fact that it has been added must be noted.

http://arlenefromisrael.squarespace.com/current-postings/2014/7/21/july-21-2014-war-update.html

 

Posted on Monday, July 21, 2014 at 05:06PM by Registered CommenterArlene in , , , , | CommentsPost a Comment | EmailEmail | PrintPrint

July 20, 2014: Who Is Like Our Nation?

The question is rhetorical. For there is no nation like Israel. 
 
Said Prime Minister Netanyahu on Friday (emphasis added):

“I have met with the commanders who are leading the IDF operation, uncommonly brave, determined and motivated commanders, with strong values. I am impressed by the motivation of our soldiers, both conscripts and reservists, and their desire to take part in the campaign. They understand that their mission is to defend Israel’s citizens.”

“Our fighters all know that they are fighting for the most just of goals – the defense of our shared home.”

http://www.algemeiner.com/2014/07/18/netanyahu-says-international-coalition-supporting-israel-to-take-systematic-and-strong-action-against-hamas/

~~~~~~~~~~

Meet here one uncommonly brave commander with strong values:

Col. Rassan Alian, a Golani Brigade battalion commander, was moderately injured last night when he was hit by shrapnel.  Doctors where he was hospitalized insisted it wasn’t time for him to leave the hospital yet. But the colonel objected: "I have a lot of soldiers over there and I need to get back to them."

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4546862,00.html

Col. Alian is not some extraordinary exception.  He represents a norm for Israeli commanders.

~~~~~~~~~~

Overnight, our operations in Gaza increased further.  That this should be necessary at all is painful, but since it IS necessary, it is possible to view the new clear-eyed determination of our political and military echelon with great satisfaction and relief.  This time we are going to do what needs to be done.

Credit: Yossi Aloni/Flash90
 
What Netanyahu also said was: The IDF is a moral military without peer; it does not aspire to harm any innocent person. We are operating only against terrorist targets and we regret any inadvertent civilian casualties.
 
http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/news/headlines-breaking-stories/248444/video-pm-netanyahus-remarks-at-the-start-of-the-special-cabinet-meeting.html
 
Continue reading for more on how Israel conducts herself.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Also overnight, in the course battle in Gaza, we have lost two more soldiers:
 
Staff Sergeant Bania Roval, a 20-year-old soldier from Holon, serving in the Paratroopers 101st Battalion, and Second-Lt. Bar Rahav, 21, from Ramat Yishai, from the Engineering Corps.  They were killed in separate actions.  Israel mourns every death.

 

Credit: TimesofIsrael
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
A major operation conducted today was against the neighborhood of Shejaia, which had been identified as a main focus of terrorist activity in Gaza.  In the course of the fighting some 40 to 50 Arabs were killed.  The IDF reminded everyone that warnings had been sent out two days ago asking civilians to please leave. These were ignored – or, Hamas advised people to ignore them. At any rate, it was only after the shelling – which has been very heavy – started that people suddenly decided it was essential to leave immediately.
 
 Palestinians flee their homes in Gaza's eastern Shejaia district on July 20, 2014, after heavy Israeli shelling that left casualties lying in the streets. MOHAMMED ABED/AFP/Getty Images) 

Credit: AFP/Getty
 
It should be noted that ten tunnels were found in this operation.
 
Among the dead were family members of Hamas leader Khalil al-Haya.
 
What happened subsequently – precise media reports vary – is that Hamas asked for a humanitarian ceasefire so the dead and wounded could be evacuated and civilians would have a chance to leave.  The Red Cross intervened, Israel agreed, and a two-hour ceasefire was set – with the proviso that if Hamas broke it, Israel would not hold fire.
 
It took forty minutes for Hamas – who was said to have wanted this ceasefire – to again start shooting at Israel. Israel returned fire, but then, in spite of this, agreed to once more hold fire and even extend the ceasefire by an additional hour, for those humanitarian reasons.
 
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4546861,00.html
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Are we crazy to do this?  I am sure some think we are.  From where I sit, this sort of humanitarian gesture is fine, AS LONG AS WE PROCEED to pummel Hamas – and don’t pull back in the face of casualties inflicted on the enemy. 
 
We are fighting two sides of the same war: the military and the public relations.  There are major anti-Israel demonstrations in a host of countries because we are so “vicious.”  If this humanitarian gesture gives people a different view of Israel (a somewhat dubious proposition) that is to the good. 
 
And, in terms of humanitarian gestures, there’s even more.  (This indeed seems certifiably nuts.)  The IDF is setting up a field hospital at the Erez Crossing between Israel and Gaza:  It is for women and children from Gaza, and includes a delivery room.
 
http://www.jpost.com/Operation-Protective-Edge/IDF-sets-up-field-hospital-at-Erez-border-crossing-for-injured-Palestinians-363541
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
What must be remembered here is that we are fighting a defensive war that is entirely justified as our civilians are being targeted. In wars, no matter the precautions, innocents are casualties.  In every war this has been so.  No one can legitimately point a finger – but the world loves to accuse Israel.
 
The ceasefire pressure is going to increase.  UN Secretary-General Ban Ki Moon is going to meet with Abbas. And Kerry is coming to the area. How did we get so lucky?
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Remember the 20 rockets found in an UNRWA school that UNRWA officials say they knew nothing about?  Well. Israeli officials are objecting to the fact that UNRWA has now turned those rockets over to Hamas.
 
http://www.timesofisrael.com/un-agency-handed-rockets-back-to-hamas-israel-says/
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
© Arlene Kushner. This material is produced by Arlene Kushner, functioning as an independent journalist. Permission is granted for it to be reproduced only with proper attribution. 
 
If it is reproduced and emphasis is added, the fact that it has been added must be noted.

http://arlenefromisrael.squarespace.com/current-postings/2014/7/20/july-20-2014-who-is-like-our-nation.html

 

 

Posted on Sunday, July 20, 2014 at 03:57PM by Registered CommenterArlene | CommentsPost a Comment | EmailEmail | PrintPrint

July 19, 2014: Keep Going, Keep Going!

Motzei Shabbat (After Shabbat)
 
I mentioned in my last post the intention to return to the issue of ceasefires, and I will do so below.  But I begin by noting that my greatest fear in this very necessary war we are waging now is that it should be terminated prematurely because of pressure for a ceasefire.  Yet, in spite of that persistent unease, I think not. It’s simply too blatantly clear that we must do now what should have been done years ago. 
 
We lost two soldiers today.  But not in combat inside of Gaza. IDF reserve officer, Col. Amotz Greenberg, 45, of Hod Hasharon, and Sgt. Adar Bersano, 20, of Nahariya, were killed when a terrorist squad infiltrated from Gaza into Israel through a tunnel.  
 
קצין וחייל נהרגו

Credit: Israel National News courtesy of the families
 
There were eight or nine terrorists, according to reports, who encountered a motorized IDF force on exiting the tunnel.  In the battle that ensued, the two soldiers were killed. One of the terrorists was shot dead, while the remainder went back into the tunnel.  They carried anesthetics and handcuffs with them, as well as arms, which meant they were going to attempt a kidnapping.
 
This, of course, simply reinforces the conviction that we have a great deal of work to do in Gaza.  The IDF has identified some 36 tunnels, five of which go into Israel.  Intensive work is being done to dismantle them, and to continue to seek out others that still exist.  I’ve picked up a couple of reports regarding plans to dig a trench that would disable tunnels near the Gaza-Israel border, i.e., those that could lead into Israel.  I’ll follow with more on this in due course.
 
Now there is talk that the operation will be stepped up further, and this is as it should be.  We need to hit hard, as quickly as possible. 
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Dismantling the tunnels, while high on the IDF agenda, is not all that must be accomplished.  Today, some 95 rockets were launched at Israel, and the south is still taking a beating. The IDF is now saying that about half of Hamas’s supply of 10,000 weapons is gone: Some 17% has been launched, while we have either hit or otherwise destroyed 30% to 40%.  But that leaves 5,000 rockets still in Hamas hands.
 
And so, along with the ground assault, we are continuing to hit hard from the air and by sea.
 
http://www.jpost.com/Operation-Protective-Edge/Israel-says-Gaza-has-used-up-or-lost-half-its-rockets-363478
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
This whole issue of all that must still be done allows me to segue directly into a report on what the State Department has had to say in the last couple of days. 
 
On Thursday, Kerry said that he “reaffirmed” our right to defend ourselves against attacks from tunnels (nice of him) but called for the ground incursion to be restricted to a precise operation against the tunnels.  In other words, we do not have a right to defend ourselves against rockets shot against our civilian population by removing caches of rockets and destroying launchers.
 
Kerry “emphasized the need to avoid further escalation and to restore the 2012 ceasefire as soon as possible.”  I would simply brush this off with the greatest of contempt, but I believe there are points that have to be made here:  The US secretary of state is working for the other side.  He would save Hamas’s collective neck here.
 
On Wednesday, four children playing near a pier on the Gaza beach were killed by Israeli fire.  Israeli officials immediately termed the incident “tragic” and let it be known that the children were near a Hamas installation that the Air Force was firing on.  One might ask (should ask) why there were children playing in the open near a Hamas installation in the middle of a war. Why (this is rhetorical) they were not in shelters, the way Israeli children are.
 
State Department spokesperson Jan Psaki told reporters that the US was “asking for a redoubling of efforts moving forward to prevent civilian casualties given the events of the past couple days.”
 
What is more, she shared the information that in a phone call to Netanyahu, Kerry had said, “We believe there is more that can be done” to protect civilians.  (Emphasis added)
 
This said to the head of state of the nation that is doing more than any nation in the world has ever done to protect the lives of civilians during a war. This is beneath contempt, and I say again that he is working for the other side and happy to give us bad press.
 
http://www.timesofisrael.com/us-restrict-gaza-operation-to-precise-action-against-tunnels/
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Now as to ceasefire issues. First, we are not returning to the 2012 ceasefire. That is what left Hamas arms intact.  If and when a ceasefire is negotiated, finally, it would have to be a different kind all together.
 
Three nations are vying for involvement in mediating that ceasefire (let it be many days away!): Egypt, Turkey, and Qatar.  This is not only because this role allows a nation to accrue prestige within the Muslim world  - we’re looking at a power issue. Israel wants only Egypt involved because of inherently anti-Israel positions emanating from Turkey and Qatar.  What must be noted here is that the US is promoting involvement by Qatar. 
 
The US is saying that it’s time to bring in another party, since Egypt is not having success.  This is likely because Egypt is not running rings around Hamas (more on this below). While Sisi, president of Egypt, considers the Brotherhood an enemy, Qatar is blatantly supportive of Muslim Brotherhood. And Hamas is a spin-off of the Brotherhood.   
 
So what’s with the US?
 
What is being exposed here – hardly for the first time – is a predisposition by the Obama administration to support Muslim Brotherhood.   I remind my readers that when Obama delivered his very first international address, in Cairo, he invited members of the Muslim Brotherhood to attend, and Mubarak was so incensed he boycotted the talk.  When Morsi – of the Brotherhood - was being overturned, the US was supportive of him.
 
Thus, all efforts by the US to be involved here must be viewed as suspect.  The US has just signed an $ 11 billion arms deal with Qatar.
 
http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Peace/2014/07/19/Qatar-Releases-Hamas-friendly-Ceasefire-Offer
 
~~~~~~~~~~     
 
I confess – and I am certainly not alone here – that I abhor the notion of a “ceasefire agreement” that includes any demands from Hamas to which we will have acceded.  The thought of it makes me rip-roaring furious. They’ve been launching rockets at our civilian population, and each rocket launched is a war crime.  So we should give these terrorists something that they are demanding in return for their ceasing their war crimes? 
 
In the past several days, a number of their “demands” have made the press.  Broadly speaking the focus is first on the release of terrorists from our prisons – specifically those released in the trade for Gilad Shalit and recently rearrested. And then on opening the borders of Gaza, via opening of crossings into Gaza from Israel and, via Rafah, from the Sinai.  There has been talk of international guarantees, so that the crossings could never be closed again – a proposal that did not exactly catch Egypt’s fancy. But there have been other demands as well, such as securing permission for the people of Gaza to pray on the Temple Mount – which was rejected out of hand by Israel, as was the idea of a prisoner release.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Earlier this past week one ceasefire proposal put forth by Hamas actually had me laughing.  They suggested a ten year cease fire, if we would fully lift the blockade of Gaza at sea.  On the face of it, both aspects of this proposal are ridiculous.  A ceasefire with an end: In ten years and one day they can, per agreement, start launching rockets again.  Of course, they’d have about half a million cutting edge rockets by then, because they would have been bringing them in by sea for ten years.
 
Yea. Right. They cannot think us that stupid.  They’re playing games.
 
But wait!  This is quintessentially Muslim.  It was a Hudna – a temporary period of quiet – they were offering, which in truth is all they offer.  And it was modeled right after the Treaty of Hudaibiya, which was negotiated by their prophet. In 623 CE, Muhammad made a ten-year peace pact with the Quraysh tribe, which controlled Mecca.  After two  years, he saw that his strength had increased sufficiently to move on Mecca. And so he devised a pretext for attacking the Quraysh, who had their guard down because, after all, they had a treaty with Muhammad’s people.  He defeated them and took Mecca.  This sequence of events is so thoroughly engraved in Muslim consciousness that even Arafat referred to it after signing at Oslo (which tells us what Oslo was worth from the start).
 
So that’s the other factor: a ten year ceasefire would not last ten years.  Or, put differently, Hamas would break any deal it signed as it was to its benefit to do so.  This is something that should never be forgotten.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Originally, Netanyahu has been talking about disarming Hamas, with international support, as part of any ceasefire agreement. I would have much to say about this, but will bide my time now.  If we do what needs to be done in Gaza, this issue may become moot.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Mentioned in closing here (with more to follow on this): Abbas is also seeking to be involved in ceasefire negotiations. To that end he will be meeting with Hamas’s politburo here Khaled Mashaal.  And where is Mashaal quartered for many years now?  In Doha, Qatar.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
A correction: The video I shared last time that showed little children being given a demonstration of rocket launchings may have come from Syria and not Gaza.  (With thanks to Bennett R. for this alert.)
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
© Arlene Kushner. This material is produced by Arlene Kushner, functioning as an independent journalist. Permission is granted for it to be reproduced only with proper attribution. 
 
If it is reproduced and emphasis is added, the fact that it has been added must be noted.

http://arlenefromisrael.squarespace.com/current-postings/2014/7/20/july-19-2014-keep-going-keep-going.html

 

Posted on Sunday, July 20, 2014 at 03:58AM by Registered CommenterArlene | CommentsPost a Comment | EmailEmail | PrintPrint

July 17, 2014: Ground Invasion into Gaza Begun

It is very very necessary, this invasion – which has been ordered by Prime Minister Netanyahu. 


Credit: TimesofIsrael

~~~~~~~~~~

So let’s stop here for a prayer for the thousands of Israel’s soldiers who are now inside Gaza. 

http://www.israelnationalnews.com/Articles/Article.aspx/15289#.U8g8IZvlrIW

“He Who blessed our forefathers Abraham, Isaac and Jacob -- may He bless the fighters of the Israel Defense Forces...
 
“May the Almighty cause the enemies who rise up against us to be struck down before them. May the Holy One, Blessed is He, preserve and rescue our fighters from every trouble and distress...and may He send blessing and success in their every endeavor.”

Amen v’amen!

~~~~~~~~~~~

I just heard an interview with Col. Richard Kemp, former commander of British forces in Afghanistan and an enormous friend of Israel.  He was down at the border of Gaza before the incursion began, he reported, and what he can say is that the troops are superbly prepared for this operation.  In fact, he said, there is no fighting force in the world that could do it better.

The troops, sitting at the border for many days, have been eager to go in.

See this article:

“...history shows Hamas is awful at killing IDF troops on the move.”


http://www.timesofisrael.com/whos-afraid-of-boots-on-the-ground-in-gaza/

~~~~~~~~~~

The operation is being led by the IDF's Southern Command, and will see close coordination between various IDF units: infantry, armored corps, engineer corps, artillery, and intelligence. They are, of course, supported by the Israeli Security Agency (ISA) and other intelligence organizations.  Israeli intelligence in Gaza is excellent and is critically important.

There was heavy aerial bombardment before the ground invasion began; the ground troops will continue to be supported by attacks from the air and the sea.

The troops went in under cover of night and in many areas there were blackouts.  Except for flares, there was little that could be seen. 

Lighting flares over Gaza

Credit: Reuters

~~~~~~~~~~

The prime minister made it clear in his announcement that the initial goal of the invasion is taking out terror tunnels.

The need for this has been evident for some time, but it was likely something that happened this morning that made action inevitable:

A Hamas tunnel that opened 250 meters inside of Israel, near Kibbutz Sufa, was utilized by 13 terrorists with full intent to launch a massacre.  They carried with them heavy weapons - 15 anti-tank weapons and Kalashnikovs - with an enormous amount of ammunition.  The blood runs cold at the thought of what they would have done, if Israeli army and security had not spotted the tunnel.  Extensive forces were waiting for the terrorists when they tried to exit.  One was reportedly killed, at least some turned back.

~~~~~~~~~~

What became apparent then was that no ceasefire, no matter the terms, would keep our people safe from terror attacks if these tunnels were left intact.

The purpose of that particular attempted massacre was very clear: Hamas was looking for a “victory” before ending the war.  Now they will pay.

There is a whole city of very sophisticated tunnels under Gaza.  They have electricity and air conditioning. And walls that are covered with tons of concrete.  (Note: the “poor” people of Gaza have cried because Israel has limited the amount of concrete brought into Gaza for building their homes, and here you have it.) 

 

Credit: ElderofZiyon

Our soldiers will not seek all of the tunnels, we are being told, but will focus on those that are within two or three kilometers of the border with Israel. 

But from what I am reading, there are a number of different sorts of actions taking place in the central, southern and northern sections of Gaza. The operation is likely to expand beyond the stated goal of dismantling tunnels.  Eighteen-thousand more troops have now been called up, and the larger goal of significantly weakening Hamas has been put on the agenda.

~~~~~~~~~~

What we are learning now is that the Security Cabinet had approved this ground operation two days ago, when it was apparent that Hamas was not going to cooperate in a ceasefire.  This is a signal lesson for us all, I think, in terms of what goes on that we, in the main, are not aware of.  This is how it is supposed to be done: with an element of surprise.

Today was a difficult day in many respects. This was, in part, with regard to false rumors of a ceasefire agreement that had been successfully negotiated (disinformation?).  I had intended to write about it, and the broader issue of ceasefires with Hamas, but the ground incursion has trumped this reporting. Hopefully I will return to it.  There are significant matters to be discussed regarding Egypt’s involvement, the desire of Qatar and Turkey to be involved, and the position of the Obama administration.  And much more.

We did have a five hour ceasefire today that had been requested by the UN so that humanitarian goods could be brought into Gaza.  We honored this; Hamas was supposed to, but did launch some rockets during that interval of time.  Once the ceasefire was over, Hamas immediately began launching a heavy barrage of rockets – with 50 in the subsequent four hours, and 100 during the course of the day.  This was one of the heaviest bombardments of the 10-day war, and surely helped move Netanyahu in the direction of ordering the troops in on the ground, as well.

~~~~~~~~~~

There is a broad consensus among commentators that we have an extraordinary window of opportunity for doing this operation now. There is even the tragedy of the Malaysian airplane that was shot down - it is occupying the media, which would normally be focused on every step our soldiers take.  Additionally, Netanyahu is in a superb place with regard to international approval because of his willingness to go with a ceasefire.  Amazingly, Egyptian Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry came out with a strong criticism of Hamas, saying it could have saved many lives if it had agreed to a ceasefire.  Deaths yet to come will be the fault of Hamas, he suggested.

What we must do however, is move quickly, as this honeymoon is no likely to last. 

~~~~~~~~~~

To strengthen your sense of what is going on in Gaza, and what the ruthless enemy we face is like, I provide the following links.  Please, use them extensively. The more people “get it,” the better:

UNRWA found 20 rockets stored in one of its school buildings. As you can imagine, they have no idea how they got there.  I have clear memories, from the days when I was investigating UNRWA, of terrorist equipment and even terrorists hidden inside UNRWA property.  But I guess they didn’t know about any of it:

http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/183016#.U8hcRZvlrIV

~~~~~~~~~~

Ruthless manipulation of the people of Gaza by Hamas, which is praising the “martyrs” who stay in their homes even when the IDF warns them to leave to avoid danger:

“’Our mighty people presented a unique example of steadfastness and perseverance and are not affected or fearful from the psychological warfare of the Occupation,’ Hamas boasted. ‘They did not respond to calls from the Occupation to leave their homes – they stayed there and did not abandon them.’”
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/183018#.U8hfDJvlrIV

~~~~~~~~~~

And then a horrible look at how their kids are influenced (appreciate it, Barbara):

https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=10152558633733398&set=vb.806093397&type=2&theater

~~~~~~~~~~

Shabbat does approach, and I do not know that I will be able to post again before its advent.  I will post as I can – and as the situation requires it - in the days ahead.

~~~~~~~~~~
© Arlene Kushner. This material is produced by Arlene Kushner, functioning as an independent journalist. Permission is granted for it to be reproduced only with proper attribution. 
 
If it is reproduced and emphasis is added, the fact that it has been added must be noted.

http://arlenefromisrael.squarespace.com/current-postings/2014/7/17/july-17-2014-ground-invasion-into-gaza-begun.html

 

Posted on Thursday, July 17, 2014 at 08:21PM by Registered CommenterArlene in , , , , , | CommentsPost a Comment | EmailEmail | PrintPrint

July 15, 2014: PHEW!

What a rollercoaster ride the last 24 hours has been with regard to our war with Hamas. 

Yesterday Egypt announced a proposal for a ceasefire: Both sides would stop firing, and then in 48 hours parties would convene in Cairo and – via an intermediary – discuss terms for a more permanent truce.  Kerry was said to be coming to Cairo to participate.

This really did not have a good feel to it, and there was anxiety in several quarters here regarding what appeared to be pending capitulation by our prime minister.  For word had come out that he was favoring acceptance of this proposal.  Was he going to say that we had done enough, and that it was now time for ‘quiet for quiet’? 

For the bottom line is that we have not done enough – I don’t care what Defense Minister Ya’alon says.  Yes, there are ways in which Hamas has taken a real beating. But I’m picking up on reports that indicate that the key leaders, sitting in their underground tunnels, are alive and well and would be ready to pick up the fight again in no time.  Similarly, because of the tunnels and the use of human shields, a large portion of the rockets remains intact and ready for future use.  One source said we’ve destroyed one-third of their rockets.  Ya’akov Amidror – who is a straight talker – says they have retained 90% of their high quality rockets. 

No, it hardly time seemed like time to call it quits if there is serious intent to make sure that Hamas does not come back at us again in two years or three. Or four or five. 

Of course, there was always the question of what Netanyahu would demand at those truce negotiations. But yet...but yet...

~~~~~~~~~~

This morning the prime minister called a 7:00 AM meeting of the eight-person Security Cabinet to discuss the Egyptian proposal.  Word came out that they had decided to accept the proposal.  Only Naftali Bennett and Avigdor Lieberman were opposed, and they were both furious.  Hearts dropped, stomachs tightened, all over Israel. This looked like caving, a disastrous show of weakness.  My own depression (and yes, I know what depression is) was heavy.

At 9:00 AM we stopped all attacks on Gaza. 

~~~~~~~~~~

But Hamas, adamantly and defiantly refusing the Egyptian proposal, kept right on firing rockets at us – at least 50 in the next six hours. 

Credit: Yonaton Sindel/Flash90

Hamas would have had trouble accepting the ceasefire because they had not achieved any significant “victories.”  With their honor-shame mental-set, it would have been near impossible to do.  Especially as they did not anticipate any major victory in the negotiations – no Gaza blockade lifted, no Hamas prisoners released. Their leaders actually complained about this: How can we stop when there is nothing indicated about what terms would be?  All that was discussed was a readiness by Israel to open crossings to let additional supplies in.

It took six hours.  At 3:00 PM, Netanyahu said, “That’s it!”  He ordered attacks on Gaza to begin again, and about half an hour later they started.

~~~~~~~~~~

Well now...we were suddenly seeing something different.  And perhaps quite brilliant.

Netanyahu had been seeing the growing criticism of Israel around the world.  The scum in Hamas, by encouraging human shields, had upped the casualties and secured multiple PR opportunities for talking about how Israel hits innocent children.  (See more about this below.)  In multiple quarters, there were anti-Israel voices being raised. Forgotten is the fact that Hamas started firing those rockets first.  Or that we abort sorties to save children.

Our prime minister (and the Cabinet?) likely saw that carrying through a major operation would have been increasingly problematic because of large scale international criticism.  The dynamic needed to be changed.

And this undoubtedly changed it.  The situation was structured so that Netanyahu became a seeker of peace, the person willing to stop shooting.  And Hamas was the party that sought violence even in the face of quiet.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu

Credit: Oliver Fitoussi

This is what Netanyahu said at a press conference earlier today with the German foreign minister (emphasis added):

"...the refusal of Hamas to honor the ceasefire "gives Israel full legitimacy to expand the operation to protect our people.

"We agreed to the Egyptian proposal in order to give an opportunity for the demilitarization of the Strip - from missiles, from rockets and from tunnels - through diplomatic means.

“But if Hamas does not accept the ceasefire proposal, as would now seem to be the case, Israel would have all international legitimacy to broaden the military operation to achieve the required quiet."

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4543685,00.html

~~~~~~~~~~

John Kerry had cancelled his trip to Cairo, because there were not going to be any ceasefire negotiations after all. From Vienna, he said (emphasis added):

"I cannot condemn strongly enough the actions of Hamas in so brazenly firing rockets in multiple numbers in the face of a goodwill effort to offer a ceasefire, in which Egypt and Israel worked together, that the international community strongly supports.

Hamas is "purposely playing politics" by continuing the rocket fire, using innocents as "human shields... against the laws of war.  And that is why they are a terrorist organization."
 
http://www.jpost.com/Operation-Protective-Edge/Kerry-cancels-trip-to-Cairo-relying-on-Egyptian-brokered-ceasefire-instead-362853

How about that?  He cannot tell us to use “restraint” now, can he?

~~~~~~~~~~

I’m going to stick my neck out here, with pure speculation, colored by a bit of intuition.  (No one has let me in on any secrets.)  I think it possible that Egypt was complicit in setting up a situation that cornered Hamas.  I think this did not just “happen.”  I’ve provided evidence in recent days of an Egyptian desire to have Israel take out Hamas.  Their role in the current scenario has helped to make it more possible.

~~~~~~~~~~

How far will Israel now go towards taking Hamas out?  This remains to be seen.  Still tonight, I hold my breath, as I wait to see what unfolds.  The nation is so weary of this, and so eager to be done with Hamas.

We are being told there is a long operation likely ahead of us, and that what must be done will be done. But this tells us nothing.  The prime minister says the war will intensify.  Lieberman is pushing for us to take over Gaza.

YNet quotes an unnamed “senior military official,” who said:

“A ground offensive could help combat the many tunnels in the Strip, where the Air Force is not effective...
 
"Our recommendations to the political leadership were clear on this issue. A ground maneuver to destroy the tunnels will take somewhere between a week and two weeks, and the troops deployed to the border are trained for this and prepared for this. There is a small but significant amount of tunnels that we've yet to expose, and they're targets in this maneuver.

[A ground offensive against the terror tunnels] "has high chances of being successful. It will require confrontation with the enemy and the evacuation of civilians, and will lead to the increase of rocket launching at Israel, but we trust the troops. The solutions will come from the fighting forces on the field, from the bottom, not just from the army command."

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4543811,00.html

I will add here that trusting the troops with solutions from the bottom is very Israeli.

~~~~~~~~~~

Data of note:

In a report it just released, CAMERA has revealed Israel has killed “mainly combatant-age males, not women or children”:  a close read of the data “shows that, as in past hostilities, the fatalities are disproportionately [compared to the overall population] among young males, which corresponds with the characteristics of combatants. Males over 40 years old are also disproportionately represented. Some of the fatalities in those over 40 years of age likely represent senior members of terrorist organizations.”

This contradicts “media reports that tried to paint Israel’s Operation Protective Edge as indiscriminately killing civilians.”

http://www.algemeiner.com/2014/07/15/watchdog-al-jazeeras-gaza-fatalities-data-indicates-israel-killed-mostly-combatant-age-males-not-women-or-children/

~~~~~~~~~~

Keep praying for our soldiers, please!  And for all of Israel.

~~~~~~~~~~

© Arlene Kushner. This material is produced by Arlene Kushner, functioning as an independent journalist. Permission is granted for it to be reproduced only with proper attribution. 
 
If it is reproduced and emphasis is added, the fact that it has been added must be noted.

http://arlenefromisrael.squarespace.com/current-postings/2014/7/15/july-15-2014-phew.html

 

Posted on Tuesday, July 15, 2014 at 05:03PM by Registered CommenterArlene in , , , , | CommentsPost a Comment | EmailEmail | PrintPrint

July 13, 2014: Faith and Struggle

I’ve written about the Iron Dome, which helps protect our citizens from rocket attacks, and about the shelters that are provided, as well as about the government guidelines that are released to keep people safe.
 
But there is a another significant factor – from my perspective and the perspective of many Jews both here in Israel and elsewhere – that I have not yet mentioned: The Almighty is watching over us and doing miracles for us.  We see it all around us.
 
Rabbi Lazer Brody, on his blog, gave an example of this.  On Thursday, a grad rocket was launched at Ashdod. It approached the vicinity of a whole complex of hi-rise apartments and then landed in the parking lot.  
 
Ashdod miracle 10.7

Credit: Lazer Beams
 
Not a single person was hurt.  And we see this again and again.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
I am not saying that no one in Israel has been hurt in the rocket attacks – we know that isn’t so.  And we cannot be sure what lies ahead in terms of casualties.
 
But the fact that injuries have been as minimal as they have been, and that to date there have been no deaths, strongly suggests that we are protected.  Hamas was out to do maximum damage to the people of Israel, and they’re failing. 
 
This Heavenly protection is evident more broadly in the fact that we are here at all, a thriving people in the midst of violent chaos and in the face of what would seem to be insurmountable odds.
 
Our task as Jews, then, is to pray, to stay united, to exhibit loving-kindness to one another, to make time for religious study and to give tzedakah (charity).  It all matters enormously.
 

Credit: Jewishmiracles
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Where are we now, with regard to the war in Gaza?  Wish I could tell you.
 
Although the message we are still receiving is that the army is totally ready for a ground invasion, and just waiting for the orders to begin, we have not begun a ground war.
 
Air Force chief Major General Amir Eshel is saying there is no need for a ground operation as his forces can do the job.  Although I am told this is a familiar Air Force refrain, there might be re-assessments as he presents his case.
 
There was one quick ground sortie inside Gaza: Very early this morning, a group of IDF naval commandos entered Gaza to destroy a weapons cache and a launching site near Gaza City in the north of Gaza.  On the way they encountered Hamas fighters.  Four of our soldiers were lightly wounded; three Hamas fighters were killed. The commandos completed their mission and returned home.
 
http://www.timesofisrael.com/naval-commandos-wounded-in-first-gaza-ground-battle/
 
In the short term we might, perhaps, be seeing more of these “quick in-quick out” operations that accomplish things that it is difficult to do from the air.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Over Shabbat, into last night and during the day today, there has been heavy fire in both directions, with large numbers of rockets launched and Israel doing considerable bombing in Gaza.
 
With all the carrying on about the civilians we’ve killed, I observe this: About 150 Arabs in Gaza are said to have been killed so far (these of course are not all civilians). The number will, clearly, shift upwards over time but this is the number I have at the moment. While over 1,200 targets have been hit by the Air Force  That is (in approximate terms) one Arab in Gaza killed for every eight targets hit.  This is an incredibly densely populated area, and it is, as I see it, a remarkably low casualty rate.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Among those hit in the last couple of days, by the way, have been a nephew of Hamas PM Ismail Haniyeh and the chief of police, as well as a host of “activists.” 
 
Israel took down a mosque, indicating that weapons were stored inside.  There has been information that the leaders of both the military and political wings of Hamas are in hiding in schools and hospitals.
 
All of this has such a “déjà vu” feeling about it: I’ve written about these very same behaviors in earlier wars with Hamas.  These are amoral bums who care not a bit about school children, the ill, or the sanctity of religious sites.  Or anything other than their own skins, first, and then their military and political goals.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
As of last night, it was announced by Israeli officials that there was going to be a change in tactics.  As most of the long range rockets are fired from the north of Gaza, those who live in the north were going to be advised to leave, so that there could be very heavy bombing in the region.  Israeli lawyers have said this is legal according to international law. (Sad, that we should be so nervous about this, but there it is.)
 
Phone calls and leaflets dropped from planes were being used; residents were being advised that terrorists were operating amongst them. 
 
As I write, some 4,000 Arabs have moved south – with UNRWA having opened facilities for them - and many more on the way. 
 
Palestinian families travel to a UN school in Gaza City to seek shelter after evacuating their homes in the northern strip, on Sunday, July 13, 2014 (photo credit: AFP/THOMAS COEX)

Credit: AP/Thomas Coex
 
Hamas is telling those fleeing to go back, and those who have not yet fled to stay put.  Israeli’s warnings, Hamas officials are saying, is no more than “psychological warfare...
 
“Until now, there is no reason to evacuate homes in these regions... Obeying Israeli instructions assists the enemy.”  Unspoken: While staying helps Hamas by upping the number of casualties.
 
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/182849#.U8KbspvlrIU
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
The big question remains whether Israel will stay the course – in the face of huge international pressure – until Hamas is genuinely weakened or destroyed.
 
It’s difficult not to feel unease about this especially as the UN Security Council finally called for ceasefire yesterday.  Netanyahu began making noises about receptivity to the “possibility” of a ceasefire, while Hamas remained adamant that it would not stop firing.
 
However, when I began to look at the terms Netanyahu was laying out for a ceasefire, such as a diplomatic process for dismantling Hamas’s rocket arsenal (as Syria’s chemical weapon stores were dismantled), or turning Gaza over to the PA, I understood that they were not terms Hamas was about to agree to, no matter what.  Then it began to seem more a matter of Netanyahu showing his “willingness” to the international community, as is his wont, and not a weakening by the prime minister.  He has said he would “consider” various proposals, and I’ve read that he has already rejected two out of hand.  So it does not seem a matter of his settling at this point.
 
Aaron Lerner, who is somewhat the skeptic, if not an outright cynic, on this question, seems to be optimistic.  He pointed out what he saw a very significant shift in Netanyahu’s position as spelled out at today’s Cabinet meeting. He has gone, says Lerner, from saying that the goal of the operation was "the restoration of quiet for a long period." to saying the goal of the operation was “the restoration of quiet for a long period while inflicting a significant blow on Hamas and the other terrorist organizations in the Gaza Strip." (Emphasis added)  This would preclude any “quiet for quiet” deal.
 
See Netanyahu’s full statement here:
 
http://imra.org.il/story.php3?id=64313
 
He says this war might last a long time, and Ya’alon’s statements reflect a similar position.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
I mention here a couple of news items that lead me to believe that the situation truly is different this time around.
 
Khaled abu Toameh reports that:“

Over the past week there are voices coming out of Egypt and some Arab countries - voices that publicly support the Israeli military operation against Hamas in the Gaza Strip.

“They see the atrocities and massacres committed by Islamists on a daily basis in Iraq and Syria and are beginning to ask themselves if these serve the interests of the Arabs and Muslims.

"’Thank you Netanyahu and may God give us more [people] like you to destroy Hamas!’ — Azza Sami of the Egyptian newspaper Al-Ahram.”

http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/4401/egypt-israel-hamas
 
And here we have a major Egyptian news announcer calling on Egypt to join Israel in destroying Hamas.
 
http://www.algemeiner.com/2014/07/13/egyptian-tv-announcer-calls-for-destruction-of-hamas-al-ahram-columnist-thanks-netanyahu-video/
 
What is significant here is that these pronouncements were made boldly for public consumption – these were not the usual whispers under the table. 
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Perhaps even more incredible:
 
The Palestinian Authority's envoy to the United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC) has said the PA has no hope of pressing charges against Israel in international courts - because Palestinian terrorist groups are far worse violators of international law themselves.
 
“...contrasting Israel's conduct during Operation Protective Edge to stop rocket fire from Gaza - in which Israeli forces always warn civilians before launching airstrikes - to the actions of Hamas and other armed groups, Ibrahim Khreisheh said any such move would surely backfire.
 
“...’the missiles that are now being launched against Israel - each and every missile constitutes a crime against humanity, whether it hits or misses, because it is directed at civilian targets,’ said Khreisheh.” (Emphasis added)
 
Khreisheh spoke last week on PA TV, in Arabic, of course.  See the story here and the TV segment, with translation by MEMRI:
 
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/182837#.U8LMGZvlrIV
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
So hang on, and pray!
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Worth considering, as well, on a related but slightly different issue, is what David Horovitz, editor of Times of Israel, has just written about Netanyahu’s position on a Palestinian state.  I note here that what he laments – because he is a “two-stater” far to my left – is for me a cause for genuine hope, as it likely will be for many of my readers as well.
 
“’The priority right now, Netanyahu stressed, was to ‘take care of Hamas.’ But the wider lesson of the current escalation was that Israel has to ensure that ‘we don’t get another Gaza in Judea and Samaria.’ Amide the current conflict, he elaborated, ‘I think the Israeli people understand now what I always say: that there cannot be a situation, under any agreement, in which we relinquish security control of the territory west of the River Jordan.’
 
“Not relinquishing security control west of the Jordan, it should be emphasized, means not giving a Palestinian entity full sovereignty there.  It means not acceding to Mahmoud Abba’s demands, to Barack Obama’s demands, to the international community’s demands.  This is not merely demanding a demilitarized Palestine...That sentence quite simply, spells the end to the notion of Netanyahu consenting to the establishment of a Palestinian state...” (Emphasis added)
 
http://www.timesofisrael.com/netanyahu-finally-speaks-his-mind/
 
Horovitz says this is Netanyahu finally revealing what he really intends.  I would prefer even more: A Netanyahu who speaks about our rights to build in all of the territory west of the River Jordan, but this is a step in the right direction.

~~~~~~~~~~
 
Note: When a handful of rockets had been launched over the border with Lebanon into the Galil. there was talk about Hezbollah trying to open a second front. But it has since been determined that it was not Hezbollah that launched the rockets but some Palestinian Arab group.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
© Arlene Kushner. This material is produced by Arlene Kushner, functioning as an independent journalist. Permission is granted for it to be reproduced only with proper attribution. 
 
If it is reproduced and emphasis is added, the fact that it has been added must be noted.

http://arlenefromisrael.squarespace.com/current-postings/2014/7/13/july-13-2014-faith-and-struggle.html

 

Posted on Sunday, July 13, 2014 at 04:32PM by Registered CommenterArlene in , , , , , , , | CommentsPost a Comment | EmailEmail | PrintPrint

July 11, 2014: Slowly, Thoughtfully, Agonizingly

By now I had thought our ground forces would have entered Gaza, but the operation remains on the edge of happening.

As I approach Shabbat and find I still have many preparations to attend to, I want to share only a very brief overview of what is transpiring with regard to the pros and cons of going in and what we do once we start the ground war.  We’re Jews. So we have as many opinions on the subject as we have commentators and analysts.

In the end, it seems to me we must go in on the ground because Hamas is stepping up the rocket launchings, and while – thank Goodness – no one one our side has been killed, there have been injuries at this point, at least a couple of which are serious.

Mordechai Yemin, an IDF soldier from Itamar, was seriously wounded by mortar shells yesterday while he was in the Eshkol Regional Council, near Kerem Shalom.  We are being asked to pray for his full recovery:  Mordechi Chai Ben Bracha Yehudit.

And...rockets are aimed now at the airport.  Not something we can tolerate.

Hamas is being defiant.  We must act decisively.

~~~~~~~~~~

Netanyahu – either very prudent or over cautious, depending on your perspective – has to deal with many factors.  In no way should we imagine that his job is anything but horrendous, as he weighs heavy issues.  All of those who write to me with notions of what we “must” do are advised to consider what we are facing.  We don’t have a professional army.  The IDF is composed of our boys.  Our sons and grandsons and brothers and fathers and friends.  That some of them may – or in the end, inevitably, must – die to protect the country is accepted.  But it’s heart wrenching – in times like this we think like one extended family.  And the more extensive the operation, the greater the losses will be.  What is a reasonable “trade-off” for the sake of the country, and what is excessive and foolish?     

With all of this anguish, however, a good portion of the Israeli populace, I would say, is eager to see us go in and give Hamas what it deserves.  The people want to see strength.

~~~~~~~~~~                

On the one hand, we are told that the presence of a whole network of tunnels makes it imperative that we go in.  There is no way that we can reach those tunnels by air. And they are so sophisticated - Yossi Melman calls them an “underground city” - that we cannot take out infrastructure and personnel and weaponry sufficiently without sending in ground troops.  What makes the tunnels more dangerous is that – as I have written before – some of them travel under the border into Israel, making it possible for terrorists to enter Israel for kidnappings and various terror incidents.

Another reason we must go in is because Hamas is embedding itself in hospitals and schools (nothing new), making it impossible to reach them from the air.

http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/Flash.aspx/297945#.U7_ZbZvlrIV

And yet, those same Vietcong-inspired tunnels make matters more dangerous for ground troops, as they can be surprised from behind by those who are hiding in tunnels. There are some who say that the fact of the tunnels means we shouldn’t sent our boys in. That it would be a booby trap.

http://www.jpost.com/Features/Front-Lines/Intel-Tunnel-vision-362323

~~~~~~~~~~

There are those – such as Maj. Gen. (ret.) Yaakov Amidror, former National Security Advisor and former head of research for military intelligence - saying that if we go in at all, it is not worth it unless we take over Gaza and really wipe out the entire terror network and leaders.  Otherwise Hamas will recoup and it will not have been worth the effort and the lives, as in two years or three, Hamas will be attacking us again.  He says it would take from three days to two weeks to take Gaza, and that we’d have to remain for six month to a year.

http://www.israelhayom.com/site/newsletter_opinion.php?id=9091

Avi Dichter former Shin Bet director, says something similar as well. We need to switch from a tactical to a strategic campaign that will last a year or two, he says.  Capture thousands of terrorist leaders and operators, and defeat terrorism.  This is different from going in to destroy weaponry that can be replenished. (My own question here is whether the fact that Egypt is blocking the smuggling tunnels would significantly reduce the ability of Hamas to replenish its weapon supply.  They manufacture some of their own weapons now, but the best are supplied by Iran.)

http://www.israelhayom.com/site/newsletter_opinion.php?id=9091

I will note here that these suggestions involve only a temporary takeover of Gaza. There is very little inclination to rule over Gaza indefinitely, with 1.5 million hostile Arabs, for whom we would be responsible.

And there are those – e.g., Mordechai Kedar, an academic with knowledge of the Islamic world and considerable intelligence savvy  – who insist we absolutely shouldn’t send in our boys because Hamas is laying a trap, and that there are other ways to handle matters.

http://www.israelnationalnews.com/Articles/Article.aspx/15303#.U7_XFpvlrIU

~~~~~~~~~~

One of the things Kedar suggests is that we cut off all electricity and fuel to Gaza, something which some of my readers have been asking me about. 

My response has been that there is an attitude in the Israeli government that we must be careful to never be accused of collective punishment of the civilian population of Gaza.  Aside from the fact that it may not be legal according to humanitarian international law, it would serve us very badly from a PR perspective and cause us to lose the support we have. What is envisioned is a headline that says, for example, that three people on respirators and five premature babies in incubators died because Israel cut off electricity and the hospital where these patients were did not have a working generator.

What’s being said is that the government’s legal advisors (which may primarily mean the attorney general) advise against cutting off of electricity.  But my own suspicion is that our prime minister, who is so inordinately concerned about world opinion, would, himself not go this route.

In 2007, what Israel did, however, was reduce the amount of electricity sent into Gaza without cutting it off completely, and government lawyers at that time said this was legal. This, then, might be the way to go – it would fall to Hamas to decide how to allocate available electricity and if hospitals were deprived it would be the fault of Hamas. But I don’t know that Netanyahu is about to be convinced of this.

http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/182788#.U7_cwJvlrIV

~~~~~~~~~~

Please know: At about dawn we were hit by three rockets coming out of Lebanon.  Another reason why we must act now.

~~~~~~~~~~

May Shabbat bring us peace.  And may the Almighty endow our leaders with the wisdom to make the best decisions they can.

~~~~~~~~~~

© Arlene Kushner. This material is produced by Arlene Kushner, functioning as an independent journalist. Permission is granted for it to be reproduced only with proper attribution. 
 
If it is reproduced and emphasis is added, the fact that it has been added must be noted.

http://arlenefromisrael.squarespace.com/current-postings/2014/7/11/july-11-2014-slowly-thoughtfully-agonizingly.html

 

Posted on Friday, July 11, 2014 at 10:49AM by Registered CommenterArlene in , , , | CommentsPost a Comment | EmailEmail | PrintPrint

July 10, 2014: Those Human Shields

Yet another factor in the current conflict is the willingness – indeed the eagerness - of Hamas to promote a PR advantage by putting its civilians in harm’s way.
 
This is not a new tactic.  Israel goes to the extraordinary lengths of warning Gaza residents of a house that an attack on that house is about to take place, so that they can leave in time.  Most often it is done by phone calls with an Arabic message. But there is also something called “roof knocking” which is launching of a small explosive device to warn that a large attack is imminent. 
 
Hamas is encouraging the residents not only to stay, but to go up on the roof.  You see here an article about Sami abu Zuhri, a spokesman for Hamas, admitting that they are doing this:
 
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/182729#.U75q45vlrIV

 

 
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/182716#.U75vBpvlrIU
 
~~~~~~~~~~~
 
For Hamas, it’s a win-win.  Either the house – which is likely either a house where weapons are stored or the home of an Hamas leader or both at the same time – does not get hit, as the strike is aborted by the Air Force.  Or, civilians are killed and it becomes a PR gain for Hamas – as the number of civilians killed increases.
 
For the residents themselves, who go up on the roofs, either they are confident that Israel will not strike them, or they are content to be “martyrs” for the cause.
 
This situation is possible because Israel is dealing with an enemy with no respect for human life, while we Jews have ultimate respect for human life.  This reflects an enormous moral advantage on Israel’s part, even as it sometimes generates an apparent PR or strategic disadvantage.
 
There will be, as the conflict progresses, a growing disparity between number of Palestinian Arab civilians (or presumed civilians – remember that Hamas exaggerates!) killed and the number of Israeli dead.  At present, thank Heaven, we have had no one killed. 
 
Thus it is imperative that people understand the reality in terms of the difference in how Hamas and the Israeli government are handling the situation. 
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Israel uses Iron Dome batteries to deflect incoming rockets, at least part of the time. (There are an insufficient number of batteries to be place everywhere.)
 
Iron Dome
Credit: Jewishvirtuallibrary
 
And Israel makes shelters available, especially in areas that have been most at risk for rocket attacks.  Some of the shelters are decorated, to minimize the trauma of children, which is a great concern. In some cases huge sewer pipes have been brought in to use as shelters.  There is an attempt, when kids must be inside shelters for prolonged time, to provide facilities and games to ease their way.

 

Credit: Wikipedia
 
Israelis take cover in a large concrete pipe used as a bomb shelter after a rocket was launched from the Gaza Strip.

Credit: Getty/Uriel Sinai
 
An Israeli family sleeps in a bomb shelter in the southern Israeli city of Ashkelon on Sunday (photo credit: Dima Vazinovich/Flash90)

Credit: Dima Vazinovich/Flash90
 

~~~~~~~~~~
 
Government announcements go out imploring residents to heed instructions and to stay close to shelters.  There are warning sirens (although, of course, of short duration near the border).  We have Israeli residents in the south who are spending their whole nights in shelters.
 
Take a look at how this group of Israeli kids is handled to allay their fear during a rocket alert:
 
http://www.israelvideonetwork.com/you-wont-believe-what-children-in-southern-israel-do-as-rockets-fall-from-gaza?
 
Compare this, my friends, to what Hamas is doing, and make sure as many as possible understand this situation.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
As to Hamas, every analyst is making it clear that its behavior is wrought of desperation and not strength.
 
Hamas has confronted a series of frustrations and failures recently, including the way in which the IDF hit Hamas infrastructure in Judea and Samaria, and rearrested Hamas prisoners released in the Shalit trade – all in the course of the operation to find our kidnapped students.  In addition, Hamas’s relationship with Egyptian president Sisi is not good, so it is not likely that there will be significant support from him.  (An Egyptian diplomat has just criticized Hamas leadership as having made irresponsible decisions.) While Arabs across the area (as well as Iran) are so focused on Iraq and ISIS, the Syrian civil war and other major crises that Gaza draws very little attention from them.  Hey, even ISIS is not supporting Hamas, saying that the time for confrontation with Israel is not yet.
 
Hamas, feeling isolated, strategically weakened, and short on funds, apparently figured it had nothing to lose.  Its aggressive behavior towards Israel was designed to draw attention and support from the Arab world, and, hopefully, ultimately funds.
 
But its plan is not working out as its leaders had hoped.  They are taking a beating of a sort that they never anticipated, and they are truly eager for it to stop. But there is a catch: Arab Muslim culture is honor-shame based.  They don’t do surrender well because of the shame it brings upon them.  They would only be able to agree to a ceasefire if they could point to something that allowed them to say they had “won.”
 
Thus, even today, Hamas leaders said they would stop launching rockets if Israel would release those prisoners who had been traded for Shalit and were re-arrested very recently.  In their dreams.  Then too, they are attempting to succeed at a major terror attack, which would, in their eyes, make them look like “winners.”
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Netanyahu has said we are not interested in a ceasefire right now, and he has instructed the IDF to escalate its efforts.  We have hit 800 targets in Gaza, although many more remain.  And now, finally, it is not just the homes of terrorist leaders that are being hit: it is the terrorist leaders themselves.  Reports are that we dispatched Iman Siam, who was head of rocket operations for Hamas.  Then there were three Islamic Jihad leaders, one of whom is Alaa Abed a-Nabi, a senior officer responsible for Islamic Jihad's rocket operations.
 
Peter Lerner, IDF spokesman, said on TV a little while ago, that these guys cannot expect to be involved with launching rockets at us and then think they can just safely get in their cars or on their motorcycles.  It’s about time!
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
At this moment in time, it does appear that our ground forces are on the verge of going into Gaza.  By the time you read this, it may well have happened. 
 
Four brigades are at the border with Gaza and one or two more are still to come.
 

Credit: Israelmatzav
 
 
As of last night, IDF Chief of Staff Gantz had approved all plans for a ground incursion. 
 
And we have sent messages by phone to 100,000 residents of Gaza, in Beit Lahia, Beit Hanoun, and Absan, telling them to leave the area immediately.
 
But, incredibly (or not so incredibly), Hamas has told them not to leave.
 
http://www.timesofisrael.com/hamas-tells-gazans-to-ignore-idfs-call-to-leave-border-area/
 
There you have it, folks: on a very large scale.  Human shields.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
A senior government official, speaking on condition of anonymity, has told Times of Israel that:
 
’Today, we’re not interested in a Band-Aid. We don’t want to give Hamas just a timeout to rest, regroup and recharge batteries, and then next week or in two weeks they start again to shoot rockets at Israel. Such a quick-fix solution is not something we’re interested in.’

”The current airstrikes at Gazan targets aim to ‘deplete and dismantle Hamas’s ability to attack us,’ the official said. Because of the ‘new strategic reality in his region,’ Israel needs to make sure that the terrorists’ ‘ability to replenish and rearm their stockpiles of weapons is more difficult than it was in the past. We’re dulling their sword, and we’re making sure their ability to sharpen that sword again is more difficult.’”
 
http://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-doesnt-want-a-ceasefire-aims-to-deal-hamas-long-term-blow/
 
If that is what we are about to do, I say Baruch Hashem.  And may the Almighty watch over our fighting boys. Because it’s frightening, for their sake, and I do not pretend otherwise.  They, however, are eager and ready to go.  Do not think otherwise!
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Again today, in the course of writing this, I had to take a break because the siren was sounding warning us of a rocket incoming.  I went to the safe place in my apartment, and after the siren stopped, my windows rattled.  I knew this had been caused by an explosion.  Now I’ve learned that four rockets were shot at Jerusalem. Two were intercepted by the Iron Dome (and that is perhaps what caused my windows to shake) and two landed in an empty field.
 
I felt no fear during this time, but when it was over I felt an enormous sadness – that we should have to endure this.  Not much longer, I pray.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
Whatever the rhetoric, there is considerable caution about the ground operation we may be about to embark on.  The traps that await our soldiers in a very densely populated area are many. 
 
But many believe that there is no way to accomplish what must be accomplished solely from the air.  Weapons caches are hidden in civilian areas, so that they cannot be reached from the air. And there is, as well, a network of tunnels that are intended for incursions into Israel, that cannot be identified from the air. 
 
What is said to be key here is that goals be carefully and realistically defined. The term used is the need for “an exit strategy.”  We have to be able to say, OK, we’ve done what we needed to do, and we can leave.  The concern is that we might get entangled in a way that leaves goals unclear or allows Hamas to claim “victory” because it appears we couldn’t accomplish what we set out to do. 
 
I do know that the IDF has been planning and training for this possibility for a long time.
 
And there are even those who are predicting a very major effort, as Yuval Steinitz did the other day, that involves a temporary takeover of Gaza.
 
I’m not included in military planning sessions, needless to say, and so I cannot tell you what will transpire next.  I have laid out the possibilities and the issues, to the best of my ability. And now we will see...
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
One other point here that I think is extremely significant with regard to our need to be tough right now.  Yes, we have to dismantle or severely reduce Hamas’s ability to hit us again at at time of their choosing.
 
But deterrence in a broader sense is also critical now.  At our north, there is Hezbollah and ISIS, and other jihadist groups. Right now they are not interested in taking on Israel, because they are otherwise occupied. But that does not mean they do not have intentions of hitting us at some future point.  Our message to them must be one of resolve and strength. They must understand what awaits them if they challenge us.
 
~~~~~~~~~~
 
© Arlene Kushner. This material is produced by Arlene Kushner, functioning as an independent journalist. Permission is granted for it to be reproduced only with proper attribution. 
 
If it is reproduced and emphasis is added, the fact that it has been added must be noted.

http://arlenefromisrael.squarespace.com/current-postings/2014/7/10/july-10-2014-those-human-shields.html

 

Posted on Thursday, July 10, 2014 at 05:15PM by Registered CommenterArlene in , , , , , | CommentsPost a Comment | EmailEmail | PrintPrint

July 9, 2014: Proportionality and Other Matters

There is a widespread – but very erroneous – impression that if an enemy attacks, a proportional response means a nation can only return what was received and no more. That is, the mistaken impression is that if Hamas shot one rocket, we could only shoot one rocket back.

International law, however, defines proportionality very differently: it is a question of legitimate military goals and intentionality.  Put very simply, we would not be restricted to only shooting one rocket back at Hamas, but rather doing what is necessary (within certain defined limits) to ensure that Hamas does not shoot any more rockets.  That is a legitimate military goal.

Luis Moreno-Ocampo, who was the Chief Prosecutor at the International Criminal Court in 2003, wrote this about proportionality:

“Under international humanitarian law and the Rome Statute, the death of civilians during an armed conflict, no matter how grave and regrettable, does not in itself constitute a war crime. International humanitarian law and the Rome Statute permit belligerents to carry out proportionate attacks against military objectives, even when it is known that some civilian deaths or injuries will occur. A crime occurs if there is an intentional attack directed against civilians...or an attack is launched on a military objective in the knowledge that the incidental civilian injuries would be clearly excessive in relation to the anticipated military advantage (principle of proportionality).”

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportionality_(law)#International_humanitarian_law

~~~~~~~~~~

The proportionality has to do with the relationship between the damage inflicted and the legitimate military goal.  What must be assessed, wrote the Chief Prosecutor, is:

(a) the anticipated civilian damage or injury;
(b) the anticipated military advantage;
(c) and whether (a) was "clearly excessive" in relation to (b).

Another way of phrasing it: former president of the International Court, Rosalyn Higgins, explained that proportionality "cannot be in relation to any specific prior injury - it has to be in relation to the overall legitimate objective of ending the aggression."

http://israelisoldiersmother.blogspot.co.il/2008/12/world-of-understanding-israels.html

~~~~~~~~~~
 
The sort of bombing we are doing is entirely legitimate and proportional to our military goals of making it impossible for Hamas to launch rockets at our people. If in the process some civilians in Gaza are hit, our military action remains entirely legitimate.  Do not believe otherwise.  In point of fact there are bound to be civilian deaths because Hamas uses civilians as human shields and places its arsenal of weapons in civilian areas.

Were Israel to decide to carpet bomb Gaza to make Hamas stop launching rockets, that would be clearly disproportionate civilian destruction in relation to the goal of stopping Hamas.  But that, of course, is something we would never, ever do.  We are, in fact, extraordinarily careful to avoid civilian deaths whenever it is possible to do so. We actually place phone calls to homes, warning families to get out, before we bomb the houses.

What is not legitimate according to international law is the sort of deliberate targeting of Israeli civilians that Hamas is doing day in and day out.  Here the intentionality is to hit civilians.

And yet, as we see day in and day out, the international community draws an outrageous moral equivalency between Israel’s actions and those of Hamas.

When the State Department calls on both sides to “act responsibly,” you know what a joke this is.

~~~~~~~~~~

But it’s actually much worse than this, as Israel is – incredibly – turned into the aggressor.  As Human Rights Watch reported:

“UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon refuses to name the perpetrators of the attacks ‘from Gaza.’ No mention is made of ‘Hamas.’ And while the rockets should ‘stop,’ what is really bothering the UNSG is alleged Palestinian victims. ‘The Secretary-General is extremely concerned at the dangerous escalation of violence, which has already resulted in multiple Palestinian deaths and injuries as a result of Israeli operations against Gaza.’
 
”...As for the notoriously anti-Israel UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay, she had this to say: ‘From a human rights point of view, I utterly condemn these rocket attacks and more especially I condemn Israel's excessive acts of retaliation.’" (Emphasis added)

http://www.humanrightsvoices.org/site/articles/?a=8116

~~~~~~~~~~

I share here a video that effectively (and amusingly!) presents the situation we confront (with thanks to Raima S.)

https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=4575217092927&set=vb.1066815202&type=2&theater

~~~~~~~~~~

Part of what the international community does is attempt to pin the blame for Hamas’s violence on Israel, because Israel has not attended to the “legitimate rights” of the “Palestinian people.”  (As if deliberate targeting of civilians by Hamas would be acceptable even if this were the case, which it is not.)

We see this with Ban Ki-Moon, who said, "the unsustainable situation in Gaza will also need to be addressed in its political, security, humanitarian and development dimensions as part of a comprehensive solution."

Philip Gordon, a special assistant to US President Barack Obama and the White House coordinator for the Middle East, at a conference sponsored by (surprise!) Haaretz, made it clear that the Obama administration still expects a negotiated settlement between Israel and the PA, based on the ‘67 armistice line.  Now he says this?  Inconceivable that he ignores the current violence from Hamas, and the fact that it is part of a unity government.  But there it is.

“Jerusalem,” he declared, “should not take for granted the opportunity to negotiate” a treaty with Palestinian Authority Mahmoud Abbas, who has proven to be a reliable partner.

http://www.timesofisrael.com/top-obama-official-blasts-israel-for-denying-palestinians-sovereignty-security-dignity/

Daft. And maliced.

~~~~~~~~~~

So let’s take a look, just for a moment, at Fatah, which is Abbas’s party.

Palestinian Media Watch tells us that Fatah put up on its Facebook page today an announcement that:

“One god, one homeland, one enemy, one goal” unites Hamas, Fatah and Islamic Jihad.

 http://palwatch.org/main.aspx?fi=157&doc_id=11956
 
~~~~~~~~~~

While Khaled abu Toameh writes that:

“At least two Fatah armed groups announced that they had started firing rockets at the ‘settlements’ of Ashkelon and Sderot, cities inside the pre-1967 borders of Israel, with another Fatah group claiming responsibility for firing 35 rockets into Israel since Sunday.”
http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/4396/fatah-rockets

The use of the word “settlements” is a tip-off to the fact that Fatah considers Jewish presence even within the ‘67 armistice line to be an illegitimate “occupation,” i.e., they want it all.

~~~~~~~~~~

Abbas, our “reliable partner,” says Israel is committing “genocide” in Gaza.  Sigh...

~~~~~~~~~~

The Elder of Ziyon put up a posting about “What Reporters Need to Know” during the current Gaza operation.  But I think the points are so good that everyone needs to know them.

His major points:

1) It is a mistake to assume that all casualties are the result of Israeli airstrikes.

Traditionally, the number of Gaza rockets that fall short and never reach Israel, or that explode as they are fired is over 35% and sometimes as high as 80%!”

Then there are “work accidents” and civilians killed when guns are shot off during funerals.

2) It is a mistake to assume that casualties and damage are the direct result of Israeli airstrikes.

Many airstrikes hit weapons caches and explosives that cause a larger explosion than the strike itself.

3) It is a mistake to believe that casualties are civilian when they are not.

Terrorists, who are combatants, most frequently wear civilian clothing. And Hamas is eager to inflate the “civilian numbers.”

Do see the entire posting. 

http://elderofziyon.blogspot.co.il/2014/07/what-reporters-need-to-know-during.html#.U7007mflrIU

~~~~~~~~~~

Be aware as well that pictures put up about the war in social media are sometimes deceptive: http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-trending-28198622

~~~~~~~~~~

The war goes on.

They are still launching rockets at us – including at the center of the country and even farther north.  Rockets have landed just south of Haifa, in Hadera, Zikhron Ya’akov (where someone was mildly hurt), Casaerea and Hof Bonim.

In some of the attacks that are farther away, Iranian long-rang missiles such as the Fajr5 and M302 are being used.

Needless to say, the south – particularly Sderot and Sha’ar Hanegev - is being hit hard.

More than 225 rockets have been fired at Israel since the beginning of the operation.

~~~~~~~~~~

But we are hitting hard inside of Gaza, as well.

According to Minister of Defense Moshe Ya’alon, who spoke today to Army Radio:

”We'll continue with strikes that will exact a very heavy price from Hamas. We are destroying arms, terror infrastructures, command systems, Hamas institutions, regime buildings, terrorists' houses, and killing terrorists of various ranks of command.

"We will continue to hit Hamas and other terror groups in Gaza Strip from the air, sea and ground to ensure the safety of Israel's citizens."

Saying “from the ground” obviously implies a ground operation.  There are multiple hints about the fact that this is about to occur, but we’re still not there. The reserve troops still have to take their places in Judea and Samaria, to replace the regular troops who must be moved to the border with Gaza.

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4540419,00.html

~~~~~~~~~~

The IDF spokesman said today that the next stage is being prepared and that this will be a long operation.

And then there is this astonishing statement from Intelligence Minister Yuval Steinitz:

“Despite the fact that it will be hard, complicated and costly, we will have to take over Gaza temporarily, for a few weeks, to cut off the strengthening of this terror army.  If you ask my humble opinion, a significant operation like this is approaching.” (Emphasis added)

And so this sounds very serious indeed. 

~~~~~~~~~~

But there remains unease here in Israel that the operation will be terminated before it should be, that the ground operation will never be actualized, and that talk such as Steinitz’s is simply a form of verbal saber rattling – a threat.  After all, this was just his “humble opinion.”

For we have Netanyahu’s words today, after the Security Cabinet met.  He is still saying, “the operation will expand and continue until the fire toward our towns stops and quiet returns." But the idea is that we are supposed to remove their capacity to hit us again!  Not just make them stop now.

And there is the fact that, while we announce we have destroyed the homes of key Hamas leaders, we deliver a warning first so that families are not hit, and many of the leaders themselves are still walking this earth.

~~~~~~~~~~

Several reports are encouraging with regard to the concerns I’ve expressed here.

Khaled abu Toameh tells us that for all the bravado of leaders of Hamas, they are stunned by the power of Israel’s attack and reeling.

http://www.jpost.com/Operation-Protective-Edge/Hamass-distress-signals-362015

~~~~~~~~~~

Apparently Egypt is unlikely to mediate a ceasefire as it has in the past.  This situation “comes at a time of mounting tensions between the new government in Cairo and Hamas. [Hamas backed the Muslim Brotherhood in its battle with Egyptian president Sisi.]

“‘There is no mediation, in the common sense of the word,’ said Egyptian foreign ministry spokesman Badr Abdelatty.”

And then we have this:

“A senior Hamas official pledged that militants would not ‘surrender’ in the face of the latest air strikes on Wednesday.

“There are no ceasefire talks, in the conventional sense.  There are ongoing contacts.  The Israelis are not interested in mediation, they are looking for surrender,’ said Osama Hamdan, who is based in Beirut.” (Emphasis added.)

http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/182712#.U71erpvlrIU

This, then, may truly be an operation that is qualitatively different.

~~~~~~~~~~

“The Israel Air Force has destroyed more terrorist targets in Gaza over the past 36 hours than it did throughout the whole the 2012 clash with Hamas, a senior security said Wednesday.”

http://www.jpost.com/Defense/IAF-destroyed-more-targets-in-36-hours-than-in-whole-of-2012-clash-362122

~~~~~~~~~~

Security is on high alert because Hamas is hoping to initiate a major terror attack as a way of shifting the balance.

Yesterday five Hamas terrorists entered Israel via the Mediterranean at a beach near Ashkelon and were killed by the IDF.

http://www.timesofisrael.com/frustrated-hamas-seeks-a-quality-terrorist-attack/

~~~~~~~~~~

© Arlene Kushner. This material is produced by Arlene Kushner, functioning as an independent journalist. Permission is granted for it to be reproduced only with proper attribution. 
 
If it is reproduced and emphasis is added, the fact that it has been added must be noted.

 http://arlenefromisrael.squarespace.com/current-postings/2014/7/9/july-9-2014-proportionality-and-other-matters.html

 

Posted on Wednesday, July 9, 2014 at 01:18PM by Registered CommenterArlene in , , , , | CommentsPost a Comment | EmailEmail | PrintPrint